LiveWire Network Peer Answers Peer Support Teen Forums Tech Forums College Forums 691 users online 165644 members 1442 active today Advertise Here Sign In
TeenCollegeTechPhotos | Quizzes | LiveSecret | Video | Dictionary | News | FAQ
You have 1 new message.
Emergency Help
Until you sign up you can't do much. Yes, it's free.

Sign Up Now
Membername:
Password:
Already have an account?
Invite Friends
Active Members
Groups
Contests
Moderators
5 online / 46 MPM
Fresh Topics
  LiveWire / My Forums / Resources / Emergency Help Center / Viewing Message

Viewing Message
From: (Not Displayed) Received: 5:48 pm on May 5, 2008 Return to Inbox
Subject: Some more serious relationship advice.
I'll try to keep this short and straight to the point.

I'm 17, she's half a year older.

I was friends with this girl for a short while, roughly five months. I was there for her when she broke up with her boyfriend of a year in a half (whom she stopped loving, apparently.) We hung out more and more, and I may have led her on. We held hands and put our arms around each other's waists, and I honestly thought it was harmless. I knew it was coming though, when one day she told me she didn't want to beat around the bush anymore, and she liked me and wanted to know where this is going.

I told her we'd best stay friends. I won't get into the reasons, but in short there was no spark. I felt nothing for her.

We stayed friends. She made it clear she was not giving up, but was not inappropriately persistent, and we had a good time hanging out. Then she got back together with her old boyfriend. I couldn't believe it - still, she once again made it clear she'd rather be with me, and was only getting back together with him because she could not stand being alone. I should note that he's a nice guy, and he's crazy about her. I despise him for reasons that have nothing to do with her though.

He was heartbroken, and begged her to take him back.I guess he's happy now...

Anyway, this is where things get interesting. She was supposed to come to a classical concert which I was performing, which meant a lot to me (the concert and seeing her there as a friend). She did not show up, and did not return my consequent calls. Several days later, she texted me like nothing happened apologizing lightly for not being able to make it. I politely made it clear that I wanted to hear some sort of reason for it. She became upset, and cut off all the ties.

I keep in touch with her friend, who made it clear to me that she's doing it out of spite, because she still has feelings for me. I thought it was understandable, though a nasty thing to do. I texted her about two weeks later (she hasn't returned my initial twenty-something calls after the concert) apologizing for leading her on, saying I realize how much that must suck. She accepted the apology and said she would talk to me when she felt ready.

Let me make a few things clear. I know for a fact she'd still be with me and is not happy with her boyfriend. It has been a month since the concert, and we haven't spoken. She just posted a xanga (blog) entry about how she wishes we had a chance and how she had a dream about me.

So here's the thing... I've come to realize that while I do not have immediate feeling for her, I very much value her friendship, and can not predict where time may have taken our relationship. I want to give it a shot, just hang out more and see where things would go, but you can see how that's a problem. Breaking her BF's heart is a part of it (I am sure she would be willing to give it a shot), but I can't stand the fact that she would just sit there and look at the phone ringing with my name on it, and not pick up. I understand why she lost contact, but she knew well enough she could have just asked to take some time off, and I made it clear her friendship meant a lot to me. Should I get over my pride, call again (she'll likely pick up), and ask her to go see a movie, making it clear we're going as friends, to get to know each other better and see where things might go?r should I leave thing behind me?p> Comment please. .

Search for more eHelps from this member »

Add Reply Return to Inbox

Replies
My advice, in a nutshell, is leave her be. In time she may get over her feelings for you once she realises they are futile, and she may well then decide that she wants to get in touch with you as a friend. In the mean time I think that it's going to be too hard for you to do anything with her that won't be misinterpreted and end up causing her heartache.

If you do start being friend with her again now on the basis that you want to see where it goes then how does her boyfriend figure in your plan? Is he to break up with her immediately while you just try being friends or is he to wait around and see how things go for you both?

From her perspective - what is she to do? She's to break up with her current boyfriend in order to "see how things go"? Isn't that basically just leading her on again? Even if you say that you don't know and you're not sure and you want to just share her company again for now, you must see that from her perspective she will be full of hope and full of optimism that you are going to turn around at some point and kiss her. When you don't do that then she's going to feel let down all over again and you'll be back to square one.

It sounds to me like you really love her as a friend and maybe as a sister in a way, but if there is no spark then I don't think you are going to find one suddenly with time. I think any suggestion that you even want to look is just playing with her feelings too much.

I think you sound like an intelligent and  thoughtful person, but you seem to be overlooking the fact that she is a person with feelings to. You seem to be blind, though, to the fact that you are playing with her feelings like they are their for your own gratification. You owe it to her in your role as her friend to make your boundaries clear, to decide where you stand and then to act accordingly. You seem to think a lot about her-as-your-friend but not of you-as-her-friend. I think perhaps you need to star thinking about what it is you have given her and what it is that you can give to her in the future. That why when she is ready to see you as a friend and to resume that relationship with her you might find it easier not to lead her on and to make sure that she knows where she stands.

Posted at 4:21 pm on May 8, 2008

Well I have been in a similar situation, both as the person who has been lead on, and the person who has done the erm leading.

First you say that you had no immediate spark for her, but by the end of the Ehelp you were considering maybe hanging out and see where it goes. Please don't do this I tried to do this, and it just worked out horribly. If there is no spark in the first place and its just a friendly caring thing and you try and push things it will just make things 100 times worse. You may even start resenting her.

Secondly just give the girl time. It must be frustrating when you miss her friendship and you know shes not happy with her boyfriend but she is hurt. A guy did the same sort of thing to me and it took a while but I got over him eventually and we are cool now. Maybe you need to give her that space so she can get over you and then you can maybe start on the road back to friendship. Its hard but these things just happen sometimes. Don't blame yourself for leading her on, because it would probably have happened anyway.

I hope it all works out.  

Posted at 3:43 am on May 6, 2008

Add Reply