LiveWire Network Peer Answers Peer Support Teen Forums Tech Forums College Forums 329 users online 173652 members 427 active today Advertise Here Sign In
TeenCollegeTechPhotos | Quizzes | LiveSecret | Video | Dictionary | News | FAQ
You have 1 new message.
Emergency Help
Until you sign up you can't do much. Yes, it's free.

Sign Up Now
Membername:
Password:
Already have an account?
Invite Friends
Active Members
Groups
Contests
Moderators
1 online / 61 MPM
Fresh Topics
  LiveWire / Teen Forums / The Intellectual Forum / Viewing Topic

Abortion and...
The Value of Human Life
Replies: 37Last Post Dec. 17, 2005 7:52am by Bizilbur
Pages: 1 2 3  Next » Email Print Favorite
Web Resources: Rape Myths Dispelled, Help & Information about Rape
USA Rape, Abuse and Incest Hotline: 1-800-656-HOPE (1-800-656-4673)
Web Resources: Teen Pregnancy Facts, Abortion Facts
USA Youth Crisis Hotline: 1-800-448-4663
The Great Jar

Novice
Reply
Quote: from abspwnsyou at 6:01 pm on Dec. 10, 2005

Then again, you are one of the ones who have been attempting to spam the intellectual forum.

Yep, you mofo.

-------
Free Online Tutoring!
Algebra, Geometry, Trigonometry, Calculus, and Physics. If interested please PM me.


3:24 pm on Dec. 10, 2005 | Joined July 2005 | 20 Days Active
Join to learn more about The Great Jar New Jersey, United States | Straight Male | 177 Posts | -1117 Points
Brother Ook

Dairy Product Addict

Patron
Reply
What I've always disagreed with in your arguments Abs is how you try and use science to prove a moral point. Sure fetuses may have human DNA but does that really make a difference?

I just can't see how someone could equate an unformed little blob of cells with a baby. To my mind it just isn't anything but potential for human life.

-------
Slab: Jus' say 'AarrghaarrghpleeassennononoUGH'


10:30 pm on Dec. 10, 2005 | Joined April 2005 | 393 Days Active
Join to learn more about Brother Ook British Columbia, Canada | Straight Male | 4891 Posts | 8741 Points
abspwnsyou

Dairy Product Addict

Ad Free
Reply
Gametes are potiental for human life, but when the two combine and create a new individual, that is no longer potiental, it is an actual life.

What is life other than a blob of cells?

It could also be taken down to the level of prime matter just being molded via the demiurge...

-------
¡Vive la República de Tejas! ¡Libertad de los Estados Unidos de América! ¡Recuerden el Liberty y lo que los zionistas le hicieron!


10:45 pm on Dec. 10, 2005 | Joined Mar. 2005 | 427 Days Active
Join to learn more about abspwnsyou Texas, United States | Straight Male | 17556 Posts | 20511 Points
Liverwire


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
Quote: from katyduck at 5:23 pm on Dec. 10, 2005

Quote: from Bud2400 at 10:07 pm on Dec. 10, 2005

Could a pro-lifer please explain one thing to me?  

 Exactly how is a fetus alive in the way we are?  How would it feel bad to "die" if it was never conscious and really thinking?  Separate DNA, moving, etc. seem irrelevant to me when one can't even "feel" its own existance.  

 If anyone could convince me that they are just as alive as humans are, then I'd be an ardent pro-lifer.


Actually, it's been proven that children in the womb, at very early stages of development (please don't ask me for figures as I can't quite remember them, but I do recall it being at a very early stage in the pregnancy), experience pain. Babies are in immense pain while being aborted, and it has even been reported that they are known to cry in the process (nobody likes pain, right?). It hurts me to think of this..


Do you eat meat?

Did you know that animals are capable of feeling pain? Nobody likes pain, right?

Did you know that mothers are capable of experiencing pain? And crying? And dying during childbirth?

-------
White and yellow like a burnt manuscript – of an owl’s efficient turd.


11:38 am on Dec. 11, 2005 | Joined Aug. 2005 | 34 Days Active
Join to learn more about Liverwire United States | Transgendered Female | 138 Posts | 1203 Points
abspwnsyou

Dairy Product Addict

Ad Free
Reply
That is nice to know because plants also feel pain, but we all know that nobody would ever harm an innocent little plant now would they?  I mean they are cute and fuzzy and so awesome...

-------
¡Vive la República de Tejas! ¡Libertad de los Estados Unidos de América! ¡Recuerden el Liberty y lo que los zionistas le hicieron!

11:49 am on Dec. 11, 2005 | Joined Mar. 2005 | 427 Days Active
Join to learn more about abspwnsyou Texas, United States | Straight Male | 17556 Posts | 20511 Points
Brother Ook

Dairy Product Addict

Patron
Reply
Quote: from abspwnsyou at 10:45 pm on Dec. 10, 2005

What is life other than a blob of cells?

Life to me is a mind and the ability to communicate. The body is nothing other than the organic sack that carries the mind around.

-------
Slab: Jus' say 'AarrghaarrghpleeassennononoUGH'


1:16 pm on Dec. 11, 2005 | Joined April 2005 | 393 Days Active
Join to learn more about Brother Ook British Columbia, Canada | Straight Male | 4891 Posts | 8741 Points
Nikki


Belle

Patron
Support Leader
Reply
I've always been against abortion, but a huge amount of factors can alter a persons opinion. For example, would you suggest that a 12 year old girl who was pregnant kept her baby, purely because it would be murder for her to go through with an abortion?

-------
.:Faut souffrir pour etre belle:.
He still gives me the butterflies - [06.07.07] ♥
She was everything beautiful and different

10:49 am on Dec. 13, 2005 | Joined Dec. 2002 | 1369 Days Active
Join to learn more about Nikki England, United Kingdom | Straight Female | 16774 Posts | 38356 Points
abspwnsyou

Dairy Product Addict

Ad Free
Reply
She made the choice to create that baby at the age of 12 did she not?  Who took their pants down and went at it?

Then again in how many states is it illegal to have sex at the age of twelve?

-------
¡Vive la República de Tejas! ¡Libertad de los Estados Unidos de América! ¡Recuerden el Liberty y lo que los zionistas le hicieron!


1:38 pm on Dec. 13, 2005 | Joined Mar. 2005 | 427 Days Active
Join to learn more about abspwnsyou Texas, United States | Straight Male | 17556 Posts | 20511 Points
Nikki


Belle

Patron
Support Leader
Reply
Quote: from abspwnsyou at 9:38 pm on Dec. 13, 2005

She made the choice to create that baby at the age of 12 did she not?  Who took their pants down and went at it?

Then again in how many states is it illegal to have sex at the age of twelve?


Yes, I agree that she made that choice, but there is also the subject of rape/sexual abuse etc.

-------
.:Faut souffrir pour etre belle:.
He still gives me the butterflies - [06.07.07] ♥
She was everything beautiful and different


2:05 pm on Dec. 13, 2005 | Joined Dec. 2002 | 1369 Days Active
Join to learn more about Nikki England, United Kingdom | Straight Female | 16774 Posts | 38356 Points
abspwnsyou

Dairy Product Addict

Ad Free
Reply
Maybe you should attempt to learn how to read?

If you ever do figure that difficult skill out, then you would see why what you just attempted to say is a load of bullcrap.

-------
¡Vive la República de Tejas! ¡Libertad de los Estados Unidos de América! ¡Recuerden el Liberty y lo que los zionistas le hicieron!


2:23 pm on Dec. 13, 2005 | Joined Mar. 2005 | 427 Days Active
Join to learn more about abspwnsyou Texas, United States | Straight Male | 17556 Posts | 20511 Points
Brother Ook

Dairy Product Addict

Patron
Reply
I don't see how anyone who thinks it murder is ok with it in any case.

Yeah it's killing a child but it's ok because she was raped!

This shows that there is indeed a difference between fetuses and babies in your mind because I seriously doubt you'd be ok with killing a baby because the mother was raped.

-------
Slab: Jus' say 'AarrghaarrghpleeassennononoUGH'


3:06 pm on Dec. 13, 2005 | Joined April 2005 | 393 Days Active
Join to learn more about Brother Ook British Columbia, Canada | Straight Male | 4891 Posts | 8741 Points
Bud2400


Guru

Patron
Reply
The 12 year old girl in this scenario, and so many others, made the choice to have sex and that's her own dumb fault, but I don't deem it necessary that she must suffer the consequences of it.

Why bring another life into the mix and use it as a tool of punishment?  It seems absurd to me and almost devalues life, in my opinion.  Life, to me, is more than that and by aborting it before it has ever tasted life seems harmless as it has yet to exist in the first place (consciously, or have a soul; whatever you call it), therefore the only "pain" felt is to those who already exist.  


3:12 pm on Dec. 13, 2005 | Joined Dec. 2004 | 1067 Days Active
Join to learn more about Bud2400 Washington, United States | Straight Male | 5786 Posts | 22693 Points
abspwnsyou

Dairy Product Addict

Ad Free
Reply
I personally oppose abortion due to rape, but I do at least understand some of the rational for it.  Not sure if I'd be able to vote for that to be illegal or not.

-------
¡Vive la República de Tejas! ¡Libertad de los Estados Unidos de América! ¡Recuerden el Liberty y lo que los zionistas le hicieron!

8:11 pm on Dec. 13, 2005 | Joined Mar. 2005 | 427 Days Active
Join to learn more about abspwnsyou Texas, United States | Straight Male | 17556 Posts | 20511 Points
lunasantin


Soothsayer

Patron
Reply
The abortion debate is retarded. No one goes about it right. Both sides have phrased all of their points such that there will be no productive exchange of ideas. There is only one question that needs to be answered; all else is secondary.

Obviously, human beings have the right to live.

Obviously, human beings have the right to control their body.

Those two precepts are non-debatable; they are important blocks of the foundation of modern Western society. Similarly, it's actually rare that these two precepts will conflict. The only situation I can think of, where they do, is pregnancy.

So there's only one question we need to ask: what is a human?

What seperates humanity from all other species? What makes us unique in this world, perhaps in this universe? How are we distinct from cockroaches and bacteria? What's the dividing line, there? Is it genetics? Consciousness, self-awareness? Intelligence? Use of tools, adaptability? Language? Religion, the presence of a soul?

That is the only question which strikes me as truly relevant to the debate on abortion. Once something is a human being, it would be a violation of those precepts to kill it.

But please, search for truth, not a way to just make more rhetoric. Don't look for the answer that proves you right, but actually be honest, and look for the answer that is most truthful. Unfortunately, there has yet to be an answer to this question that will satisfy all or, I suspect, even most, but we must try.

-------
Make love, not traffic.


8:56 am on Dec. 15, 2005 | Joined Oct. 2005 | 297 Days Active
Join to learn more about lunasantin California, United States | Straight Male | 4552 Posts | 10881 Points
ChampagneSupernova


Advisor
Reply
A fetus has a parasitic relationship with its carrier (the mother's body.) It is a parasite, in the most scientific form of the word. It cannot reason, it cannot exist on its own; therefore, it is not a human. With the exception of partial-birth abortion, which is despicable and wrong, abortion should be legal for up to the middle-to-the-end of the second trimester, with medical abortion (through pills) most preferable. It should not take you more than six months to decide if you want to keep it. (I say "it" because it is not a baby; it's a select combination of bodily fluids that has the POTENTIAL to become a baby.)

I could never have an abortion, but I could also never ask the 12 year old who was raped to have the baby she was forced into carrying, and I could never ask a woman who used all available types of birth control and still got pregnant, despite being conscientious, and who is too poor to give the child a good life, and is against adoption, to give birth. It's not my decision to make for someone else, for it's her body, whether I agree with it or not. I cannot limit her rights.

I nearly choked on my water when you said plants can feel, by the way. You were kidding, right?

... I think your arguments themselves are pretty weak, not to mention pedantic and illogical.


11:23 am on Dec. 15, 2005 | Joined Dec. 2005 | 38 Days Active
Join to learn more about ChampagneSupernova Pennsylvania, United States | Straight Female | 221 Posts | 611 Points
Pages: 1 2 3  Next » Email Print Favorite

Quick Reply

Prereq. Intellectual Test
You are signed in as our guest.

Looking for something else?
 

  LiveWire / Teen Forums / The Intellectual Forum / Viewing Topic