LiveWire Network Peer Answers Peer Support Teen Forums Tech Forums College Forums 737 users online 223004 members 901 active today Advertise Here Sign In
TeenCollegeTechPhotos | Quizzes | LiveSecret | Memberlist | Dictionary | News | FAQ
Member Spotlight
OneSquared
Favs: Harry Potter, Gone with the Wind, Lord o...
Mood: Sick
You have 1 new message.
Emergency Help
Until you sign up you can't do much. Yes, it's free.

Sign Up Now
Membername:
Password:
Already have an account?
Invite Friends
Active Members
Groups
Contests
Moderators
6 online / 29 MPM
Fresh Topics
  LiveWire / Teen Forums / World News & Current Events / Viewing Topic

Vietnam II
Replies: 19Last Post June 4, 2008 8:40pm by Shogun villimax
Welcome to LiveWire!
We're Stronger Together.
Join the Community
Pages: 1 2 Email Print Favorite
Choice Votes Percent  
Yes 9 25%
No 18 51%
1/4 8 22%
Vote Now! 35 Votes Cast
airemaye


Yeah, what do we do?

Patron
Reply
It wouldn't say it exactly parallels Vietnam. They're two different wars and two different situations. But there are many similarities, to be sure.

I'm too lazy to go into anymore detail right now. Maybe later.

-------
And while the seagulls are crying,
We fall but our souls are flying.


9:40 pm on June 3, 2008 | Joined: Feb. 2006 | Days Active: 1,025
Join to learn more about airemaye Illinois, United States | GLBT Ally Female | Posts: 12,599 | Points: 34,548
LiveWire Humor
Miden

Connoisseur

Patron
Reply
Quote: from matto at 11:34 pm on June 3, 2008

Quote: from Miden at 9:33 pm on June 3, 2008

Nope. Anyone who claims they are close to the same needs to read up on history some more.
Full of shit.  Please explain further.  Oh wait, you can't.


-Completely different political situations  

-like others have pointed out. The scope and death toll is nearly incomparable.

-The public outrage of Vietnam was much worse. Sure the Iraq war is very unpopular, but we have not seen the likes of public outrage that occurred due to Vietnam.  

-The War in Iraq and Vietnam involved different enemies, different theatres of war, different motives, different in just about every way.  

-Many would even argue the claim that Iraq is even a true War


The points you made, although not all incorrect, are generalized and misconstrued.

Post edited at 9:45 pm on June 3, 2008 by Miden

-------
It may be true that you can't fool all the people
all the time, but you can fool enough of them to rule a
large country. -- Will Durant


9:43 pm on June 3, 2008 | Joined: April 2007 | Days Active: 319
Join to learn more about Miden Alabama, United States | Straight Male | Posts: 2,870 | Points: 6,160
Bud2400


skeet skeet skeet

Patron
Support Leader
Reply
The war in Iraq doesn't parallel Vietnam a whole lot.  You could stretch things and make it seem like there are similarities, but that's all they are - stretches.

With Vietnam, the US was focused in defending South Vietnam from the North Vietnamese and refused to invade North Vietnam - only bomb them.  Hence the US wasn't trying to "defeat" the enemy, but rather, wear them out to the point where they stop fighting.

Whereas with Iraq, the US has already gone in, totally defeated the opposing Iraqi army, and even executed the Iraqi leader.  Now the US is focused with trying to occupy the country and rebuild it, which was never the case with Vietnam.

Of course, let's not forget that the guerilla fighting in Vietnam was much more severe because the dense jungles and cities in Vietnam make that kind of fighting much easier.  You have that kind of fighting in Iraq, but as most of the country is a large open desert or flood plains, you don't have it so much.


I'd say the war in Iraq has far more parallels to the US occupation of the Philippines in 1898 to 1913, where the US had just destroyed the Spanish and took their colony of the Philippines.  At the same time, the Philippines were fighting for their independence from the Spanish and believed the US was helping them, only to be stabbed in the back and have a new colonial master - the US.  The US justified itself and its casualties in the Filipino resistance on the grounds that it's developing and westernizing the Philippines, which is very similar to today's US's justifications for Iraq (except without the element of terrorism, which has been emphasized ever since Iraq was proven to have not had any WMDs - thus even these two situations paralleling each other is a stretch).


11:03 pm on June 3, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2004 | Days Active: 1,388
Join to learn more about Bud2400 Washington, United States | Straight Male | Posts: 9,731 | Points: 38,245
obvious child


Guru

Ad Free
Reply
In some ways it did. Vietnam and Iraq both shared poor frameworks and goals and both had their goals and rationales somewhat change through out the course of the conflict.

Pre-Surge Iraq can be argued to be very similar to Vietnam in that counterinsurgency tactics were not used and the results were much of the same. Furthermore, neither the SVA nor the Iraqi army are capable of standing on their own and require the Americans to do most of the work. The Hmong are kind of like the Kurds, but that's somewhat of a stretch.

Also, Vietnam was to prevent Communism from spreading, essentially maintaining Western Influence and stability. If you understand the real reason for Invading Iraq, it's similar in maintaining western influence and resource stability.

But the biggest similarity is the failure of the US to adapt to the environment and enact counter insurgency tactics until Petreaus and his brain trust were given authority.

-------
"I give the probability of this working at zero" - Dan DeMatteo


12:57 am on June 4, 2008 | Joined: Sep. 2005 | Days Active: 946
Join to learn more about obvious child Oregon, United States | Straight Male | Posts: 14,337 | Points: 24,821
Shogun villimax


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
We havent cut an run this time!

-------
Soon the power will be mine!

8:40 pm on June 4, 2008 | Joined: Aug. 2007 | Days Active: 243
Join to learn more about Shogun villimax Ohio, United States | Straight Male | Posts: 3,159 | Points: 5,654
Pages: 1 2 Email Print Favorite

Quick Reply

You are signed in as our guest.

Looking for something else?
 

  LiveWire / Teen Forums / World News & Current Events / Viewing Topic