One is a guy and one is a girl.
the truth is i really prefer girls [i'm bi]

the girl is sweet and shy but we often have nothing to talk about. last night we got together. i'm the first girl she's been with.

the guy is one of my best friends and i love him to bits. the trouble is it's often really awkward between us and i don't know if i could see him as a boyfriend. we can really talk.

good conversation vs. good sex

-------
Kiss my eyes and lay me to sleep...

Same with the girl.

And this case, you need to push them both a little harder, and wait and see how they both react. Don't try being with them both at the same time and keeping it from them.

-------
Bring me my monocle. I want to look rich.