LiveWire Network Peer Answers Peer Support Teen Forums Tech Forums College Forums 499 users online 223146 members 608 active today Advertise Here Sign In
TeenCollegeTechPhotos | Quizzes | LiveSecret | Memberlist | Dictionary | News | FAQ
Member Spotlight
stephanie15
Cool Things: Scary Movies
Mood: Musical
You have 1 new message.
Emergency Help
Until you sign up you can't do much. Yes, it's free.

Sign Up Now
Membername:
Password:
Already have an account?
Invite Friends
Active Members
Groups
Contests
Moderators
3 online / 38 MPM
Fresh Topics
  LiveWire / Teen Forums / Short Stories & Poetry / Viewing Topic

please, please, PLEASE, read. I NEED feedback
Replies: 21Last Post Dec. 23, 2008 12:08pm by save the world
Welcome to LiveWire!
We're Stronger Together.
Join the Community
Pages: 1 2  Next » Email Print Favorite
( Birches )


Quality Control Engineer
Reply
Its so hard to get feedback on what I write, so can some one/people take the time out of their day to read and give feedback.

'Sergeant Major, I know that when I signed myself up in 1914 I would be putting my life on the line, but I didn't know it was going to be like this. Or come to this.' He paused. 'But I don't want to have to go out and meet something that I don't understand.'

Corporal Harte sighed to himself as William stood with him watching the men labour on the Albert-Amiens road. They carried stones from a horse a cart to fill craters in the road caused by German shelling.  Harte had taken off his beret to wipe his face with his handkerchief. The sun beat down on the still day as it approached its highest point.

Corporal Thomas Harte had worked as a conductor on the electric trams in Manchester. He was thirty three years old, a quiet man by his nature. He had the calmness and sensibility required of a Corporal in the Labour Corps. William was afraid that the lack of action seen for several months might slow the men and make them lazy. Harte, he believed, was a man who would keep his squad sharp, and it appeared so as they toiled in the heat. But this war, this monotonous life they lead where they woke up each morning to repair the fresh shell craters in the roads they had worked on just a few days ago. Vital work it may be as convoys waited for them to complete the repairs, but the war dragged on and questions and arguments over what they were 'fighting' for flared up.

When they landed in France as Royal Engineers Harte had a full head of hair, now, as they stood in the hot morning sun in Picardy, Harte was balding fast. Transferred into a new unit, the Labour Corps, an unarmed force used to maintain roads and light railway. Similar to the work they had done before as Royal Engineers, only unarmed. William couldn't see the sense in taking away a soldier's gun. It's like taking away his purpose.

'It's not that I'm afraid.' He continues. 'I just want to see my wife and children. It's been two years we've been here Sergeant Major.' He furrowed his brow.

William turns to Harte, 'Corporal Harte, we'll get home someday. Make sure those craters are filled by noon.'

Those were the only words of encouragement he could offer as he left Harte to supervise the men alone. It wasn't easy being Sergeant Major of a company of older men. They had wives and children they had never left at home alone. Some, he thought, would even prefer to be in the front line than labouring over craters at the rear. Of course they weren't free from danger. They were regularly under fire from the German's guns which they were always in range of. That surely had some effect on the men's nerves. They had no dug outs or trenches to hide in.

As Royal Engineers in 1916 they had gone in as support in some assaults, which had gotten the men's adrenaline racing. It was what they signed up for, Kitchener's call in 1914. They were all classed as labourers, being older men, short sighted or having some other shortcoming that prevented them from being infantry. William was promoted to Company Sergeant Major immediately on account of his occupation, a builder's foreman and a qualified master joiner, that and his military experience.

'Company Sergeant Major Till' Captain Bristed called. 'How long will it be until this road is repaired?'

'About half an hour sir, it would be faster but it's almost noon and it's getting hot.'

'Spiffing weather though isn't it Sergeant Major?' Bristed looked up at the clear blue sky, stroking his moustached, slightly greyed. 'We had weather like this nine months of the year in New Zealand. I don't know why I ever went back to those dull grey days in England. Well at least I got this war Sergeant Major. Newspapers say the Bosch are on their last legs.'

-------
See her with the green dress?
She talked to me at the bar.


3:17 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2007 | Days Active: 56
Join to learn more about Birches England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | Posts: 194 | Points: 760
LiveWire Humor
SpasticTurnip


Visionary
Reply
effort in reading that tbh.

-------
The Game.
You lost it.

3:18 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2008 | Days Active: 98
Join to learn more about SpasticTurnip Ireland | Bisexual Female | Posts: 6,891 | Points: 9,707
GothiK8DragoN


Quality Control Engineer
Reply
Wow... I could really picture the setting

3:19 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2008 | Days Active: 49
Join to learn more about GothiK8DragoN Florida, United States | Questioning Male | Posts: 415 | Points: 922
spaceykayce


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
Haha. Yay for New Zealand. :) I think it's good. I would add/change some grammar, but I'm not sure if you're looking for petty feedback like that, or feedback on the piece as a whole.

-------
"Life can only be understood looking backward.
It must be lived forward."

3:21 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2008 | Days Active: 30
Join to learn more about spaceykayce New Zealand | Straight Female | Posts: 854 | Points: 1,444
( Birches )


Quality Control Engineer
Reply
Quote: from spaceykayce at 11:21 pm on Dec. 19, 2008

Haha. Yay for New Zealand. :) I think it's good. I would add/change some grammar, but I'm not sure if you're looking for petty feedback like that, or feedback on the piece as a whole.

everythign and anything

-------
See her with the green dress?
She talked to me at the bar.


3:21 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2007 | Days Active: 56
Join to learn more about Birches England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | Posts: 194 | Points: 760
noraa


Soothsayer

Patron
Reply
Your writing style doesn't draw the reader in as much as it should. I'm sorry to be so blunt, but it doesn't. And opening with a quote sometimes works, but in this piece it doesn't. You need to set up your scene more, be more interestingly descriptive. Also, you say their names and titles way too much. Switch for a pronoun every once in a while.

I like it though. I like how it ends, and your writing is excellent. Just spice it up a bit.


3:22 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Sep. 2007 | Days Active: 449
Join to learn more about noraa New York, United States | Label Free Female | Posts: 8,017 | Points: 11,393
( Birches )


Quality Control Engineer
Reply
Quote: from NoNoNora383 at 11:22 pm on Dec. 19, 2008

Your writing style doesn't draw the reader in as much as it should. I'm sorry to be so blunt, but it doesn't. And opening with a quote sometimes works, but in this piece it doesn't. You need to set up your scene more, be more interestingly descriptive. Also, you say their names and titles way too much. Switch for a pronoun every once in a while.

I like it though. I like how it ends, and your writing is excellent. Just spice it up a bit.


Its just the beginning of the second chapter. I kept titles to show the formality of the army and how william's rank earned respect.

-------
See her with the green dress?
She talked to me at the bar.


3:26 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2007 | Days Active: 56
Join to learn more about Birches England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | Posts: 194 | Points: 760
Jokerboy719


Quality Control Engineer
Reply
I thought this was something else,

Nice writing skills.

-------
In a world full of darkness... I'm the only light.


3:27 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Nov. 2008 | Days Active: 19
Join to learn more about Jokerboy719 New York, United States | Straight Male | Posts: 674 | Points: 897
spaceykayce


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
Is this part of a book you're writing, or is it a school assignment or something like that?

-------
"Life can only be understood looking backward.
It must be lived forward."

3:28 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2008 | Days Active: 30
Join to learn more about spaceykayce New Zealand | Straight Female | Posts: 854 | Points: 1,444
( Birches )


Quality Control Engineer
Reply
Quote: from spaceykayce at 11:28 pm on Dec. 19, 2008

Is this part of a book you're writing, or is it a school assignment or something like that?

a book.

Whats the verdict?

-------
See her with the green dress?
She talked to me at the bar.


3:32 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2007 | Days Active: 56
Join to learn more about Birches England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | Posts: 194 | Points: 760
LoveLikeBlaqkWinter


Quality Control Engineer
Reply
Its gewd well duns^^ Tho if you really want feedback add me on DA and me and my friends will give their opinions - LoveLikeBlaqkWinter,
XxXx.

-------
RiOtGiRl911XxX

3:38 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: April 2008 | Days Active: 38
Join to learn more about LoveLikeBlaqkWinter England, United Kingdom | Label Free Female | Posts: 319 | Points: 716
spaceykayce


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
Quote: from Birches at 12:32 pm on Dec. 20, 2008

Quote: from spaceykayce at 11:28 pm on Dec. 19, 2008

Is this part of a book you're writing, or is it a school assignment or something like that?

a book.

Whats the verdict?


I like it. I'd want to read more. :)

-------
"Life can only be understood looking backward.
It must be lived forward."


3:40 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2008 | Days Active: 30
Join to learn more about spaceykayce New Zealand | Straight Female | Posts: 854 | Points: 1,444
save the world


Enlightened One

Patron
Reply
Quote: from Birches at 12:17 am on Dec. 20, 2008

'But I don't want to have to go out and meet something that I don't understand.'
This rings a bell - namely, it's very close to the words Tommy Lee Jones says in the beginning of the movie No Country For Old Men.

But I don't want to push my chips forward and go out and meet something I don't understand.
I can't be sure if that was intentional or not, but it makes a bad impression, as it gives the feeling of having heard it somewhere before and repetitiveness isn't a good thing. You should be careful with such stuff.

'It's not that I'm afraid.' He continues. 'I just want to see my wife and children. It's been two years we've been here Sergeant Major.' He furrowed his brow.
Tense inconsistency.

3:54 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Oct. 2006 | Days Active: 829
Join to learn more about save the world Poland | Straight Male | Posts: 2,913 | Points: 16,102
( Birches )


Quality Control Engineer
Reply
Quote: from Save the world at 11:54 pm on Dec. 19, 2008

Quote: from Birches at 12:17 am on Dec. 20, 2008

'But I don't want to have to go out and meet something that I don't understand.'
This rings a bell - namely, it's very close to the words Tommy Lee Jones says in the beginning of the movie No Country For Old Men.

But I don't want to push my chips forward and go out and meet something I don't understand.
I can't be sure if that was intentional or not, but it makes a bad impression, as it gives the feeling of having heard it somewhere before and repetitiveness isn't a good thing. You should be careful with such stuff.

'It's not that I'm afraid.' He continues. 'I just want to see my wife and children. It's been two years we've been here Sergeant Major.' He furrowed his brow.
Tense inconsistency.

Ok, although I have that film on DVD I was not aware of the plagiarism.

Secondly, can you explain the inconsistency, please? I don't see it and would like to address it.

-------
See her with the green dress?
She talked to me at the bar.


4:45 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2007 | Days Active: 56
Join to learn more about Birches England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | Posts: 194 | Points: 760
spaceykayce


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
'continues' is present tense, 'furrowed' is past.

-------
"Life can only be understood looking backward.
It must be lived forward."

4:49 pm on Dec. 19, 2008 | Joined: Dec. 2008 | Days Active: 30
Join to learn more about spaceykayce New Zealand | Straight Female | Posts: 854 | Points: 1,444
Pages: 1 2  Next » Email Print Favorite

Quick Reply

You are signed in as our guest.

Looking for something else?
 

  LiveWire / Teen Forums / Short Stories & Poetry / Viewing Topic