Yes, a lot of our novices come to this site expecting something a lot different. The thing is, they are encouraged and supposed to read both the FAQ's and the Guidelines. They are generally supposed to read these to get a feel of what they should/shouldn't do on this site. I think it is perfectly fair to ban them if they come and advertise on LiveWire. Don't get me wrong, but it's a perfectly valid reason. Generally these members come to this site with the intent to Advertise. So giving them a warning won't really do any good, especially if they are going to continue to spam with their advertisements. Seriously, look back at some of the spam members we have had recently.
For instance, the Billy May's advertiser. Username Billy Mays, posting the Same message everywhere he went. Although this member wasn't banned, he obviously came for the purpose of spamming a ridiculous message on LiveWire. Generally they will die down and realize they aren't wanted/needed/being cared about, and go away. Such as he/she.
I suppose what I'm saying, in an overview, is that they should be banned if they fail to abide by the new rules. I doubt that moderators ban them off the wall. They receive informal warnings like everyone else. If they continue to not follow the rules, well, that is there choice. This message is sent out to every novice. Hopefully they take the time to read it. The first point, being to read the guidelines. If they choose not to, that is their fault and they are putting themselves at risk. I get your point, but I don't agree at all.
-------
███ΞSecrecyΞ███