A Question to Racial Nationalists of Any Kind -- LiveWire Teen Forums

So you're saying that large waves of migrants tend to retain their own cultures within the overall culture, and they're more or less able to simply because they have enough numbers to exclude themselves from the rest of society? And through this, there are cultural clashes between this isolated group, other isolated groups, and society at large?
It would make sense, but again, why not just argue for their assimilation? If they want to come live here, why shouldn't they just assimilate and you be happy with that? The second and third generations usually do abandon this community at some point and join the mainstream society after all.

Sometimes it's too late - the culture is changed. Then, there are separate cultures in one nation. These cultures are influenced by a 3rd world nation, and influenced THEIR third world nation, usually pushing the US itself downwards.

And what would the problem with this be? We're talking within the US only, not worldwide. It's not as if the culture of their home country would disappear if they decided to move and assimilate into the US.

That's different. But the thing is - is it really possible for them to do that? Is it likely?
My experience and what I've seen/heard of tell me: no.

So because minorities tend to be poorer than usual, receive welfare more, and affirmative action is in place, you argue for having a society free of minorities?
Why not just denounce affirmative action, welfare, and all that, and push for greater integration so that these minorities aren't stuck in such low socioeconomic positions in society?

Who says nobody wants this? It's pretty much a lost cause.

And they have to be willing to integrate, don't they?

If you grow dependent on the government and aspire for nothing more believing that you can't achieve anything more because you're of whatever race, what would you expect? Greater integration (which isn't forced) would lead to an end of that.

Well, you can't expect it to happen can you? People want to practice their own culture, when more than one exists, they clash.

Nah, the most sensible course of action is to separate the white individuals of today from the whites of the past. Whites today are not guilty because whites in the past enslaved others, engaged in imperialism, passed discriminatory laws, etc. Most minorities I've known do this, but there are quite a few, and whites too, who don't. If you really oppose this, then you'd enlighten them to that fact as opposed to simply running away from the whole thing.

"enlighten them to that fact"
I've been doing so Bud, and I get called a racist, White Supremacist, race-hating, genocide instigating, KKK member, Nigger lynching Nazi.

The truth isn't always accepted y'know.

There is no loss of individuality by assimilating into a new culture. You're still an individual who exhibits individual characteristics. You still have your origins in a foreign place. You just simply live in a new culture. Same person, different circumstances. No loss of individuality - it's merely just a change.

Cultural individuality is lost.

Which would lead you to believe that they'd seek out their differences between each other more in terms of individual differences as opposed to collective differences (like race), no?

But their area is built to accommodate these cultural qualities - such as there being a lot of Mexican food in Texas, yet a lot of German food in North Dakota.

I asked you first. At our present state, it'd be far more convenient to simply have everyone in the US to assimilate into one culture with each individual adding his or her own piece of their culture into that mix and integrate. You clearly need to establish and prove some kind of significance and why the benefits would be greater than the costs if what you suggest is to ever work out.

"adding his or her own piece of their culture"
They shouldn't add anything. This isn't Mexico, therefore Mexican culture has no place here. This isn't Japan, therefore Japanese culture has no place here.

Instead of mixing up cultures and destroying previously existing characteristics, why not let people observe multiculturalism themselves? Then, the people that want it can have it - and the people that don't want it don't have to be in it.

-------
"One of the Germans... would frequently snatch a child from the
woman's arms and... tear the child in half... Such incidents...
occurred all the time." - A Year in Treblinka, Yankel Wiernik,
Treblinka's "most authoritative eyewitness"

608 users online 222891 members 1542 active today Advertise Here