LiveWire Network Peer Answers Peer Support Teen Forums Tech Forums College Forums 402 users online 225365 members 280 active today Advertise Here Sign In
TeenCollegeTechPhotos | Quizzes | LiveSecret | Memberlist | Dictionary | News | FAQ
Member Spotlight
tigard
I haven't filled out my profile...
Mood: Scheming
You have 1 new message.
Emergency Help
Until you sign up you can't do much. Yes, it's free.

Sign Up Now
Membername:
Password:
Already have an account?
Invite Friends
Active Members
Groups
Contests
Moderators
3 online / 22 MPM
Fresh Topics
  LiveWire / Teen Forums / Religion & Philosophy / Adding Reply

Quoting Post
Archived Topic: It will not be bumped to the top of the forum.
Topic Will Your Generation Break the Cycle of Superstition?
Membername   Not a member? Sign Up Free (takes 20 seconds)
Password   Forgotten your password?
Post

Font:   Size:   Color:

FAQ Keyword Search:
Post Options
Favorites Manager
Notify me of new replies to this topic by email
Notify me of new replies to this topic by private message
Original Post
LogicandReason Posted at 2:45 pm on Dec. 29, 2008
Superstition is a product of an agrarian society as farmers try to propitiate gods in hopes of avoiding the capricious destructive nature of the weather and elements.  But here we are in 2008, almost 2009.  We have science and we are industrial...will this generation unleash itself from the ignorance and bigotry of ancient thinkers and strive towards egalitarianism?  I can only hope.

Replies
Destinys Child Posted at 10:34 am on Jan. 14, 2009
Quote: from LogicandReason at 5:08 am on Jan. 14, 2009

Quote: from Destinys Child at 5:00 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from LogicandReason at 6:25 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from Destinys Child at 4:13 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from LogicandReason at 7:24 pm on Dec. 29, 2008

Why do theist hate science so?
Where did you get that idea?

 

 As an example, the Christian campaign against using the HPV vaccine.  Some birth control!  And speaking of birth control, Christians, despite statistics showing that birth control and sex education dramatically lowers teen pregnancy, teach their children abstinence...and then rail against abortion!  But their most amazing fight against science is the Evolution debate that rages on only in the US.


Is that all science is to you? Birth control and evolution? And that makes all theists anti-science? That makes a lot of sense. And you call yourself LogicandReason???

Those are but a few examples.  From the time of early atomic theory (Democritus/5th century BCE) theist have been trying to thwart science because it exposes supernatural metaphysics for the mythology it is.  

Take the cases of Copernicus and Galileo.

Now let's consider your reply.  In typical theistic fashion you attack the messenger rather than debate the message.  In my post I never stated all theists nor did I cite these examples as the inclusive list.  Your meme fights any explanation for reality that competes with talking snakes and suicidal deities...both pure myth.


Science doesn't deal with the supernatural or with mythology. It only examines/investigates the physical world.

No, you didn't say ALL theists but then you didn't qualify it at all. You didn't say most or some or a few, you simply said 'theists'... which would imply you believe it's inclusive of pretty much all theists.

And I believe you used those examples because you think those are the easy ones to "prove". But so far your 'message' has all been opinion. Yours.

I don't have any problem at all with science. I have a problem with foolish people who attempt to use science against God/theism/religion. That's not what science is about. And I'm not a very religious person myself.

LogicandReason Posted at 3:08 am on Jan. 14, 2009
Quote: from Destinys Child at 5:00 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from LogicandReason at 6:25 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from Destinys Child at 4:13 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from LogicandReason at 7:24 pm on Dec. 29, 2008

Why do theist hate science so?
Where did you get that idea?

As an example, the Christian campaign against using the HPV vaccine. Some birth control! And speaking of birth control, Christians, despite statistics showing that birth control and sex education dramatically lowers teen pregnancy, teach their children abstinence...and then rail against abortion! But their most amazing fight against science is the Evolution debate that rages on only in the US.


Is that all science is to you? Birth control and evolution? And that makes all theists anti-science? That makes a lot of sense. And you call yourself LogicandReason???

Those are but a few examples. From the time of early atomic theory (Democritus/5th century BCE) theist have been trying to thwart science because it exposes supernatural metaphysics for the mythology it is.

Take the cases of Copernicus and Galileo.

Now let's consider your reply. In typical theistic fashion you attack the messenger rather than debate the message. In my post I never stated all theists nor did I cite these examples as the inclusive list. Your meme fights any explanation for reality that competes with talking snakes and suicidal deities...both pure myth.

osmoticdespair Posted at 5:38 pm on Jan. 13, 2009
Southern Hemisphere says no.
Destinys Child Posted at 5:00 pm on Jan. 13, 2009
Quote: from LogicandReason at 6:25 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from Destinys Child at 4:13 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from LogicandReason at 7:24 pm on Dec. 29, 2008

Why do theist hate science so?
Where did you get that idea?

As an example, the Christian campaign against using the HPV vaccine. Some birth control! And speaking of birth control, Christians, despite statistics showing that birth control and sex education dramatically lowers teen pregnancy, teach their children abstinence...and then rail against abortion! But there most amazing fight against science is the Evolution debate that rages on only in the US.


Is that all science is to you? Birth control and evolution? And that makes all theists anti-science? That makes a lot of sense. And you call yourself LogicandReason???
LogicandReason Posted at 4:25 pm on Jan. 13, 2009
Quote: from Destinys Child at 4:13 pm on Jan. 13, 2009

Quote: from LogicandReason at 7:24 pm on Dec. 29, 2008

Why do theist hate science so?
Where did you get that idea?

As an example, the Christian campaign against using the HPV vaccine. Some birth control! And speaking of birth control, Christians, despite statistics showing that birth control and sex education dramatically lowers teen pregnancy, teach their children abstinence...and then rail against abortion! But their most amazing fight against science is the Evolution debate that rages on only in the US.

Destinys Child Posted at 4:13 pm on Jan. 13, 2009
Quote: from LogicandReason at 7:24 pm on Dec. 29, 2008

Why do theist hate science so?
Where did you get that idea?
Shogun villimax Posted at 3:32 pm on Jan. 13, 2009
Quote: from LogicandReason at 6:08 pm on Dec. 30, 2008

Quote: from Shogun villimax at 4:15 pm on Dec. 30, 2008

Quote: from LogicandReason at 2:45 pm on Dec. 29, 2008

Superstition is a product of an agrarian society as farmers try to propitiate gods in hopes of avoiding the capricious destructive nature of the weather and elements. But here we are in 2008, almost 2009. We have science and we are industrial...will this generation unleash itself from the ignorance and bigotry of ancient thinkers and strive towards egalitarianism? I can only hope.
 
 Here here!  
 Insted of beleving that everything had to come from something,lets ignore scientific fact!  
 Anything as long as there isint a god that can say what we're doing is wrong!

Yours created god to judge our actions as wrong. Prohibitions and privations in society were created in order for us to coexist, not propitiate delusional myths.



...Because If God exists then he can tell me what I'm doing is wrong!
So insted of the delusional myth of God,I'll beleve the even more delusional myth that what ever made the universe and our bodies doesin't care how we use them!
GeneCosta Posted at 6:22 am on Jan. 12, 2009
Quote: from Colleen35 at 4:35 pm on Dec. 29, 2008

Isn't science just another form of superstition, which is easier to convince the modern mindset of?

Jump off a cliff and tell me gravity is superstition.

GeneCosta Posted at 6:20 am on Jan. 12, 2009
Quote: from airemaye  

I'm a future sociology major, just go with it, okay?

Because someone who doesn't even have their sociology major said so? Sorry, I look for more prudent sources than you.

The need to explain natural happenings (most often through spiritual means) is a cultural human universal, much like the tendency to wear clothes and follow fashions, have marriage and coming of age rituals, and appreciate music and the arts.  

And conduct slavery. Wait: civilizations evolve. There's already motion in effect to have non-religion dominate the world, as it should (if we want a world based in scientific discoveries and calm, rational discussions instead of religious nonsense). In every developed world atheism and agnosticism are set to become pluralities and majorities.  

GeneCosta Posted at 6:17 am on Jan. 12, 2009
Quote: from NikkiG at 4:30 am on Jan. 11, 2009

Um as long as fucked up unexplainable shit keeps happening, I will continue to be superstious. I'm not religious, but I still believe that there's a personal force that moves things because I have experienced far too many coincidences in my life for it to be just science. I also believe in ghosts because I have personally seen them. I will believe this stuff until it is explained by science.

That's stupid. Have fun believing in the flying spaghetti monster.

Clouse227 Posted at 7:39 pm on Jan. 11, 2009
I doubt it.

Never hurts to hope though.

airemaye Posted at 7:31 pm on Jan. 11, 2009
The need to explain natural happenings (most often through spiritual means) is a cultural human universal, much like the tendency to wear clothes and follow fashions, have marriage and coming of age rituals, and appreciate music and the arts.

In other words, it's part of what makes us human and unless we change our very base instincts, we'll always have religion.

I'm a future sociology major, just go with it, okay?

LogicandReason Posted at 5:03 am on Jan. 11, 2009
Quote: from NikkiG at 4:30 am on Jan. 11, 2009

Um as long as fucked up unexplainable shit keeps happening, I will continue to be superstious. I'm not religious, but I still believe that there's a personal force that moves things because I have experienced far too many coincidences in my life for it to be just science. I also believe in ghosts because I have personally seen them. I will believe this stuff until it is explained by science.

I hear you..and that is a candid response.  Science, God, or acid trips may never explain everything to us; but how mundane if life possessed no mystery.  I posit both God and science are linguistic synonyms...just different denominations of varied 'faith.'  I choose science because it constantly allows for corrective dogma.

NikkiG Posted at 4:30 am on Jan. 11, 2009
Um as long as fucked up unexplainable shit keeps happening, I will continue to be superstious. I'm not religious, but I still believe that there's a personal force that moves things because I have experienced far too many coincidences in my life for it to be just science. I also believe in ghosts because I have personally seen them. I will believe this stuff until it is explained by science.
LogicandReason Posted at 4:25 am on Jan. 11, 2009
Quote: from draakprinses at 2:02 am on Jan. 1, 2009

Quote: from Colleen35 at 3:25 pm on Dec. 30, 2008

Quote: from LogicandReason at 5:24 pm on Dec. 29, 2008

 
  Perhaps hypothetical theory is. If you drive a car, fly on airplanes or take medicines when you are ill, then the 'superstition' must have some veracity.
 

 

 As much as praying when you're ill gives religion veracity, no?


Science is observable and measurable.


I don't think that is a fair comparison.  When we drive a car, fly in an airplane or take medicine for a diagnosed condition, we, for the most part. can predict the outcome.  Can the same be said about prayer?

While it is arguable that prayer offers psychological comfort and other benefits, the result is capricious.  Theist thank god when the 'prayer is answered.'  People offer that is is 'god's will' when the request goes unanswered.  The truth is, some things we hope for will work out and others will not.  Our scientific accomplishments offer predictable results.  As your signature quote says: "Science is observable and measurable."

Most recent 15 of 28 previous replies displayed.