LiveWire Peer Support Network

Printable Version of Topic "I have found a PLOT HOLE in the golden rule"

- LiveWire Teen Forums & College Forums (http://www.golivewire.com)
-- (http://www.golivewire.com/forums/support-teen.html)
--- The Intellectual Forum (http://www.golivewire.com/forums/forum-16-s-0.html)
---- I have found a PLOT HOLE in the golden rule (http://www.golivewire.com/forums/peer-yaioiie-support-a.html)


-- Posted by Bearsy at 3:02 am on Aug. 28, 2008

Not everyone would like to be treated the same you would.
l
-People who are allergic to your favorite food
-Masochists
-People with different preferences overall
-If you're someone who's suicidal

Discuss.


-- Posted by darKStorm at 3:46 am on Aug. 28, 2008

I've thought about the suicidal one before.

But since suicide is a sin it kind of means you don't count, maybe? I don't know for sure.


-- Posted by MotoMojo at 8:02 am on Aug. 28, 2008

I don't think that the golden rule is meant to be a universal rule capable of dictating every person's behavior in every situation as it is a general guideline that you should use with discretion depending on the circumstances. A revision for special circumstances might be, "Treat others the way you imagine they'd like to be treated."  

.02


-- Posted by palepalepeach at 9:09 am on Aug. 28, 2008

Sure, but it's still a good general rule, at least with strangers.  By the time you know a person, you know when it applies and when not.


-- Posted by Bacon at 3:42 am on Aug. 30, 2008

Quote: from MotoMojo at 1:02 am on Aug. 29, 2008


I don't think that the golden rule is meant to be a universal rule capable of dictating every person's behavior in every situation as it is a general guideline that you should use with discretion depending on the circumstances. A revision for special circumstances might be, "Treat others the way you imagine they'd like to be treated."  

.02


I agree with this man.


www.golivewire.com